In the second half of October, three houses closed within eight days in Brookwood Hills. 223 Brighton Road NE closed for $1,912,500 on October 19. 102 Brighton Road NE, a fully renovated house, closed for $2,600,000 on October 23. 49 Huntington Road NE, a Harrison Design home renovated throughout, closed for $2,850,000 on October 26. All three sold below their asking prices. In FMLS records, the median October sale came in at 96.6% of the final list price and 94.5% of the original list price.
That October pattern held for the whole year. From November 2025 through October 2026, FMLS recorded 13 detached closings under the Brookwood Hills subdivision, and all 13 closed below list. Six of them, or 46.2%, had already cut their price before they went under contract. Over the same twelve months, the neighborhood's median sale price was $503 per square foot, the highest among the intown neighborhoods a Brookwood Hills buyer usually compares it with.
Put together, Brookwood Hills still gets its premium. Sellers here get the highest price per foot in this group of neighborhoods. What they give up is time and the first number on the listing. A buyer who understands that knows where the room in a negotiation is and where it isn't.
The Highest Price Per Foot, and the Longest Wait
Here are the trailing twelve months of FMLS detached-home closings for Brookwood Hills and its neighbors, November 2025 through October 2026:
| Neighborhood | Closings | Median price | Median $/SF | Median days on market |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brookwood Hills | 13 | $1,912,500 | $503 | 42 |
| Collier Hills | 31 | $1,205,000 | $491 | 3 |
| Ansley Park | 24 | $2,127,814 | $471 | 20 |
| Peachtree Hills | 41 | $970,000 | $469 | 3 |
| Garden Hills | 38 | $1,416,250 | $463 | 8 |
| Peachtree Park | 20 | $1,130,000 | $435 | 7 |
Ansley Park is the useful comparison. Its median sale price is about $215,000 above Brookwood Hills, but its median price per square foot is $32 lower, and its houses went under contract in less than half the time. Collier Hills comes closest on price per foot at $491. Its median listing was gone in three days, and about a third of its 31 sales in those twelve months closed more than 1% under list, compared with all 13 in Brookwood Hills. All of ZIP code 30309 recorded 75 detached sales over the same twelve months, at a median $457 per square foot and 19 days on market.
Brookwood Hills is the slowest neighborhood on the list and also the most expensive per foot. It sells slowly, and it still sells at the top of this group.
Where the Gap Goes
The pattern makes sense once you count how few houses there are. Thirteen closings in twelve months is about one a month. FMLS recorded none at all in December 2025, January 2026, February 2026 or August 2026. When so few houses sell, the most recent high sale sets the asking price for the next listing. A seller looking at $2.85 million on Huntington Road prices to that. A buyer looking at the same house weighs it against $471 a foot in Ansley Park and $491 in Collier Hills, and offers closer to those numbers.
The difference between those two positions gets settled slowly. Month by month, the median Brookwood Hills sale closed between 90.4% and 97.5% of the final list price. Measured against the original list price, the range was 86.6% to 97.2%. The one July 2026 sale shows the extreme. It sat 140 days and closed at 86.6% of its original asking price, which still worked out to $504 a foot.
The spring sales went the other way. The two March 2026 closings took a median 13 days, came in at 97.5% of list and sold at a median $645 a foot. The single April closing took 11 days and sold for $2,843,700, at 96.4% of list. Neither month had a price reduction. Houses priced close to what buyers would pay sold fast and near the asking price, even in Brookwood Hills. The houses that waited were the ones whose list price started above that level.
The houses that make up the high end are mostly older homes with serious renovations behind them. Along with the October sales, 12 Camden Road NE, a 1925 Traditional with a kitchen renovated in 2016, closed for $2,500,000 on June 8. At the low end, 21 Brighton Road NE, also renovated, closed for $1,025,000 on September 9. Every sale over the year landed between those two prices. The middle half fell between $1,540,000 and $2,500,000.
Three Houses on the Market Heading Into Thanksgiving
As of mid-November, FMLS showed three active single-family listings in Brookwood Hills. None was pending or under contract, and none had been listed within the past 30 days.
- 272 Camden Road NE: $1,750,000, four bedrooms, 3,334 square feet, 33 days listed as of November 16
- 45 Montclair Drive NE: $2,599,000, five bedrooms, 6,244 square feet, 59 days listed as of November 16
- 215 Camden Road NE: $949,000, four bedrooms, 3,594 square feet, 196 days listed as of November 16
On a per-foot basis, these three sit very differently against the $503 neighborhood median. 272 Camden is asking about $525 a foot, close to where renovated houses here have closed. 45 Montclair is asking about $416 a foot, which is low for Brookwood Hills on a house of 6,244 square feet. 215 Camden is asking about $264 a foot, roughly half the neighborhood median, and has been listed more than six months. A price that far below every recent closing usually reflects the house's condition. A buyer should expect to price that work in before comparing it with the October sales.
All three listings are older than 30 days, so a buyer coming to any of them this week faces no competing new listings. That matches the year-long pattern, where most of the negotiating happened on houses that had already been listed for a while.
What the Address Means at the Club
Owning a house in Brookwood Hills also makes a buyer a resident applicant to the Brookwood Hills Community Club, the pool, park and tennis grounds in the middle of the neighborhood. Membership is optional and is not included in a purchase. According to the club's membership page, a homeowner inside the neighborhood boundaries "may apply to join the Club at any time."
The 2026 resident fees listed there are $1,600 in annual dues and an $8,500 initiation fee for an A membership with pool privileges. A B membership with park privileges is $835 a year. An S membership with pool privileges, for residents over 65, is $860 a year with a $5,500 initiation fee. Nonresidents pay $1,600 a year and a $10,500 initiation fee. They also pay a nonrefundable $250 waitlist fee and join a list ordered by application date, which the club reviews roughly February through May.
A resident homeowner applies outside that nonresident waitlist, and the resident initiation fee is $2,000 lower. Next to a $1.9 million median house, the fees are small. The ability to apply as a resident at any time is the more valuable part of the address. Club fees and terms can change, so this is general information only. Confirm current figures with the club, and take financial questions to your own advisers.
Our January look at Brookwood Hills' swim-tennis life and the August post on the neighborhood's curve away from Peachtree Road cover what that daily life looks like.
Reading One Sale a Month
A neighborhood with thirteen sales a year can't produce a reliable monthly trend. One $2.8 million renovation or one house that needs work can move the median by six figures. The trailing-year numbers above describe a price range and a pattern of behavior. They don't predict where next spring's prices will go.
The wider market helps explain why buyers had time this year. FMLS's August 2026 Market Intel report counted 397 metro Atlanta closings above $1 million in July 2026, up 14.1% from a year earlier, with the number of homes for sale up 7.4%. The Atlanta REALTORS® September 2026 market brief put metro-wide supply that month at 4.9 months, with homes averaging 30 days on market. The more expensive end of the metro market had more sales and more houses to choose from, and that gave a buyer at $1.9 million time to wait out an asking price.
For a buyer, Brookwood Hills pricing comes down to where the list price starts. The spring 2026 closings show that houses priced near what recent sales support moved quickly, while one priced at the neighborhood's best recent sale will usually wait, take a price cut and close a few percent under list, still at a price per foot above anything in the surrounding neighborhoods. Your offer should be based on how the house compares with the renovated sales on Huntington, Brighton and Camden, adjusted for how long it has been listed.
FAQ
How many homes sell in Brookwood Hills each year?
FMLS recorded 13 detached closings in the Brookwood Hills subdivision from November 2025 through October 2026, about one a month, with several months that had none.
What did Brookwood Hills homes sell for over the past year?
From November 2025 through October 2026, detached sales ranged from $1,025,000 to $2,850,000, with a median of $1,912,500 and $503 per square foot.
Do Brookwood Hills homes sell over asking?
None did in that twelve-month window. All 13 closed below list, and the median house took 42 days to go under contract.
Does buying a home include club membership?
No. Membership in the Brookwood Hills Community Club is optional, and resident homeowners may apply at any time under the club's 2026 terms.
With a year like this one, the price that matters for any one Brookwood Hills house depends on its renovation, how long it has been listed and how it compares with the October closings. Erin Yabroudy & Associates would be glad to work through those comparisons with you. If you're considering a house on Camden, Brighton, Huntington or Montclair, request a private market consultation and we'll go through the current listings with you before you make an offer. You can also start with our Brookwood Hills neighborhood page.